Wood-fired pizza oven at Pasquini's Pizzeria

Islamorada, Florida Keys

The Thin Crust
That Started
a Tradition

Hand-tossed, wood-fired, and made with the kind of care that only comes from years of doing it right. No shortcuts. No compromises. Just honest pizza in the middle of the ocean.

View Our Menu Order Now
Scroll

Wood-Fired Since Day One

Every pie passes through our wood-burning oven at over 900°F. That's the only way to get a crust that's crisp on the outside, chewy on the inside, and lightly charred at the edges.

Ingredients That Travel

San Marzano tomatoes. Fresh mozzarella from local dairies. Basil from our own garden. We source the best because our neighbors notice when we don't.

Made for This Place

Islamorada isn't just where we're located — it's who we are. Sea breeze, slow evenings, and a menu built for people who want something real after a day on the water.

Interior of Pasquini's Pizzeria with warm lighting

Our Story

We Didn't Come Here
to Make Average Pizza

Pasquini's started with a simple question: why should the Florida Keys settle for anything less than extraordinary pizza? What began as a small dream on the Overseas Highway has become a gathering place for locals and visitors who know the difference between fast food and real food.

Our dough is mixed fresh every morning. Our sauces are simmered all day. And our ovens never stop running while we're open. It's not complicated — it's just the way it should be done.

Pasquini's Pizzeria Islamorada, FL

Visit Us

Come Sit With Us

We're right on the Overseas Highway — easy to find, hard to forget. Whether you're grabbing a slice to go or settling in for a long evening, we'll have a slice ready for you.

Address 80925 Overseas Hwy
Islamorada, FL 33036
Phone (305) 517-6598
Hours Mon–Sun: 11am – 10pm
Call to Order Get Directions
Is this your business? Claim your website
Your own domain includedLive in minutes, edit anytime
Claim my website